Timbercreek Management owns the property (as well as the adjacent The Maitlands apartments). There are documents in which the owner wants to demolish it, and other documents where they are looking to renovate it, status is now unclear. 

On 8 October 2020, 34 Maitland Street (Toronto) experienced a large fire. The source of this fire is unclear at present, as is the future of the building. The exterior of 34 Maitland Street, Toronto is largely intact post-fire. 

The property dates to 1867 or 1870 and is one of 2 remaining 19th century homes with their primary elevations on Maitland Street between Church Street and Yonge Street.  Most of the southwest section of the Church-Wellesley Village neighbourhood was demolished in the mid-20th century to allow the construction of high-rise apartments and co-ops.